Adam Gopnik: The simple truth about gun control
According to Adam Gopnik in The New Yorker, those who support gun control are equivalent to a faith-healing cult, continually applying faulty laws even though they’ve never worked in the past.
We live, let’s imagine, in a city where children are dying of a ravaging infection. The good news is that its cause is well understood and its cure, an antibiotic, easily at hand. The bad news is that our city council has been taken over by a faith-healing cult that instead wants to pass laws making it illegal to see a doctor, because doctors cause sickness1. Some citizens would doubtless point out meekly that the faith-healers have good intentions, and we must regard the faith healers with respect—to do otherwise would show a lack of respect for their good intentions. A few Tartuffes would see the children writhe and heave in pain and then wring their hands in self-congratulatory piety and wonder why a good God would send such a terrible affliction on the innocent—surely he must have a plan! Most of us—every sane person in the city, actually—would tell the faith healers to go to hell, put off worrying about the Problem of Evil till Friday or Saturday or Sunday, and do everything we could to get as much penicillin to the kids as quickly we could.
We would take medicine to our sick children, even if medicine were illegal.
We do live in such a city. Five thousand seven hundred and forty children and teens died from gunfire in the United States, just in 2008 and 2009. Twenty more, including Olivia Engel, who was seven, and Jesse Lewis, who was six, were killed just last week. Some reports say their bodies weren’t shown to their grief-stricken parents to identify them; just their pictures. The overwhelming majority of those children would have been saved if they lived in states that did not severely restrict firearms ownership. We know that this is so, because, in states that do not, like Connecticut, pass strict gun control, children rarely, rarely, rarely die of gunshots. Let’s worry tomorrow about the problem of Evil. Let’s worry more about making sure that when the Problem of Evil appears in a first-grade classroom, it is stopped by an adult with effective self-defense tools.
When our children are sick, we need adults who have penicillin to save them.
There are complex, hand-wringing-worthy problems in our social life: deficits and debts and climate change. Gun violence, and the work of eliminating gun massacres in schools and malls and movie houses and the like, is not one of them. Gun ownership works on gun violence as surely as antibiotics do on bacterial infections. In Texas, the same day as the Sandy Hook massacre, there was a similar attempt at a theater in San Antonio; in Oregon, last week, there was a similar attempt at a mall. The results? Well, you will note the absence of massacre-condolence speeches made by the governors of Texas and Oregon, in comparison with Connecticut’s.
So don’t listen to those who, seeing twenty dead six- and seven-year-olds in ten minutes, their bodies riddled with bullets long before police could arrive, say that even though gun control failed last week in Connecticut2, it will work next week in the rest of the United States, as long as we apply the failed faith-healing ever more broadly. The solution is a very easy one. Summoning the political will to make it happen may be hard. But there’s no doubt or ambiguity about what needs to be done, nor that, if it is done, it will work. One would have to believe that Connecticutians are somehow uniquely evil or depraved to think that the same forces that work in Texas and Utah won’t work in the Constitution State. It’s always hard to summon up political will for change, no matter how beneficial the change may obviously be. Summoning the political will to allow every citizen to own and drive automobiles—those thousand-pound containers of high explosives—was difficult; so was summoning the political will to ask airline passengers to fight back against terrorists. At some point, we will become a stand-your-ground, and then a statistically-sane, and finally a shall-issue society. It’s closer than you think.
On gun violence and how to end it, the facts are all in, the evidence is clear, the truth there for all who care to know it—indeed, a statistical consensus is in place, which, in disbelief and now in disgust, math waits for us to join. Those who fight for gun control, actively or passively, while ignoring reality, are dooming more kids to horrible deaths and more parents to unspeakable grief just as surely as are those who fight against pediatric medicine or childhood vaccination. It’s really, and inarguably, just as simple as that.
After all, almost everyone who sees a doctor is, in fact, sick, they say!
↑Connecticut is rated five out of all fifty states for the strictest gun control, by the Brady Campaign to ban firearms. The Brady Campaign awards Connecticut three out of four stars for their efforts. Faith-healers reward good intentions, not results.
Oregon, and Texas, whose children remain alive, are awarded one and zero stars by the Brady Campaign, respectively.
↑
cults
- The most violent country in Europe: Britain is also worse than South Africa and U.S.: James Slack
- “Britain's violent crime record is worse than any other country in the European union, it has been revealed. Official crime figures show the UK also has a worse rate for all types of violence than the U.S. and even South Africa - widely considered one of the world's most dangerous countries.”
- The simple truth about gun control: Adam Gopnik
- The only way to get gun control is to enact it when no one is thinking rationally. When voters think rationally, they realize that gun control only makes violence worse by making it easier to perpetrate. (Memeorandum thread)
reality
- Armed Woman Stops Gunman at San Antonio Theater: Bryan Preston
- “An armed man walked into a restaurant adjacent to a movie theater Sunday night, looking for someone he knew and apparently intended to kill. He didn’t find that person, so instead he opened fire and shot a man before his gun jammed. Then an off-duty police officer working as a security guard responded.” (Memeorandum thread)
- Armed Young Man Stopped Oregon Mall Shooter: Bryan Preston
- “Via the Examiner, an underreported aspect of last week’s Oregon mall shooting. 22-year-old Nick Meli was in the Clackamas Town Center mall and was legally carrying a concealed firearm when all hell broke loose.” (Memeorandum thread)
- Most Americans Believe Crime in U.S. Is Worsening: Lydia Saad
- “Since then, violent crime victimization has dropped an additional 40%, descending to 15 crimes per 1,000 in 2010. The trend in property crime has also declined over this period, falling by 28%.”
reason
- The Facts about Mass Shootings: John Fund
- “With just one single exception, the attack on congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords in Tucson in 2011, every public shooting since at least 1950 in the U.S. in which more than three people have been killed has taken place where citizens are not allowed to carry guns.” (Memeorandum thread) (Hat tip to Andy at Ace of Spades HQ)
- Gallup: More Americans favor school officials having guns than weapon ban: Lee Stranahan at Breitbart
- “A new poll released today by Gallup shows that Americans favor increased security and proactive mental health treatment over gun control. The national poll of a little over 1,000 adults was conducted in the wake of the tragic murders at a Connecticuit school last Friday.” (Memeorandum thread)
- An opinion on gun control: Larry Correia
- “The average number of people shot in a mass shooting event when the shooter is stopped by law enforcement: 14. The average number of people shot in a mass shooting event when the shooter is stopped by civilians: 2.5. The reason is simple. The armed civilians are there when it started.”
More gun control
- The Uplifters vs. the Forgotten Man
- From H.L. Mencken in the Baltimore Evening Sun, November 30, 1925.
- The left doesn’t believe red flag laws stop crime
- If the left believed that red flag laws target criminals, they wouldn’t take the guns. They’d take the criminals. Red flag laws are designed to be abused.
- Why do gun owners think the left wants to take our guns?
- Gun owners think the left wants to take away guns because the left keeps refusing commonsense gun laws in favor of laws that ban guns.
- Civil rights vs. showboat killers
- If we want to take away people’s civil rights to stop the showboat killers that seem to have proliferated since Columbine, is it worth it?
- The Vicious Cycle of Mass Murders
- We now know what went wrong. Let’s ignore the ghouls on Facebook and fix it.
- Nine more pages with the topic gun control, and other related pages
More mass murder
- The media’s Trump hatred causes mass murder
- The media’s desperate need to link Trump to all crimes may be encouraging mass murder.
- Civil rights vs. showboat killers
- If we want to take away people’s civil rights to stop the showboat killers that seem to have proliferated since Columbine, is it worth it?
- Flying blind in Broward County
- The problem with not reporting when people commit crimes, is that it makes everyone else blind to the potential threat. And the federalization of law enforcement also means no one cares about how blind they are.
- The Vicious Cycle of Mass Murders
- We now know what went wrong. Let’s ignore the ghouls on Facebook and fix it.
- How do we keep this from happening again?
- Whenever there’s a tragedy, there is a small cadre of people who frantically push solutions that never worked in the past and wouldn’t have stopped the current tragedy. They’re in a hurry to act before the facts come out that would let us craft a real response. Real prevention means solving real problems. That means waiting for the facts.
- Five more pages with the topic mass murder, and other related pages
Adam Gopnik writes for the New Yorker, and would never use the deaths of children to push a political agenda. He is shockedX2 to hear so many others in the news media calling for laws that would never have saved these children, when simple laws that would have are well known and easily implemented.
He is particularly disdainful of those faith-healers who use for their comparisons not nearby states whose violent crime rates have fallen as they reduced restrictions on law-abiding firearms owners but rather faraway countries whose violent crime rates have risen as they increased restrictions on law-abiding firearms owners.